THE PHYSICS OF VACUUM & GAS FILLED HIGH VOLTAGE RELAYS
Normally we do not encourage users of GIGAVAC
relays to understand the physics of our relay technology. However,
when it comes to contact loads, some understanding can make the
relay selection a lot easier and can result in a much better selection
for your application. The chart at the end of this article provides
a comparison that indicates the best dielectric and contact materials
for specific applications. GIGAVAC's "How
to Pick a Relay - Quick
Pick" makes the selection easy. But if you want to know
why we recommend specific relays for particular applications,
you may find this article of interest and you may want to look at High Voltage Relay Designs to become better acquainted with the designs of different GIGAVAC high voltage relays. And remember, if you ever
have questions always feel free to contact Today's Experts at
GIGAVAC or our Sales
Representative in your area.
Please note, this article does not apply
to our Reed Relays.
Some history: Vacuum as a dielectric
- a new generation of relays is born
GIGAVAC sealed high voltage
relays were first developed for aerospace RF applications. The
relays were to be as small as possible, have low RF losses, have
good dielectric isolation at the rated RF voltage, and be able
to operate at various altitudes and in harsh environments. To
meet this requirement, a new generation of relays were developed
using advanced sealing methods so that vacuum could be used
as the dielectric inside the relay. The dielectric strength of
vacuum is about 8 times greater than air. And because there is
no oxidation in a vacuum, low resistance copper contacts (rhodium
for our reed relays) are used that allows the relay to carry significantly
more current than traditional open-air relays. GIGAVAC calls
these vacuum relays with copper contacts "carry
only" relays.
These new small vacuum relays quickly
gained acceptance and new applications for "hot switching" (make
and break load switching) soon developed. However, because soft
contact materials like copper and rhodium vaporize easily as the
contacts switch and deposit on the inner walls of a vacuum relay,
a "plating out" of the walls occurs
over time and there is a dielectric breakdown. To increase
the life of the relay, harder contact materials such as tungsten
and/or molybdenum were used. GIGAVAC has identified these vacuum
relays as "make & break".
SF6 Gas filled relays for high in-rush
switching and long periods of non-operation
As the new sealed high voltage relays became
more popular, other applications developed which took advantage
of the hard contact materials. These applications include high
in-rush capacitive make and capacitive discharge such as those
found in ESD test equipment, cable test equipment, heart defibrillators,
and for applications where no high voltage is applied for long
periods of time where low and or stable leakage current is needed.
Because GIGAVAC had mastered the sealing processes for vacuum relays,
GIGAVAC back-filled and pressurized with SF6 gas the "make & break" relays
with hard contacts mentioned above.
Under special circumstances,
GIGAVAC also back-fills with pressurized SF6 gas "carry
only" relays mentioned above for applications where the inrush is not too
high and where higher carry current is required. We do not normally recommend
these relays without knowing the specific application.
SF6 under pressure
has many advantages over vacuum because the leakage current is stable over
long periods of non-operation and because of the way the gas performs during
switching. SF6 is an excellent insulator but once the switch is closed
if the relay bounces the SF6 becomes easily ionized and carries
the arc current. This makes the relay electronically bounceless
and dramatically reduces contact wear. GIGAVAC calls these SF-6
gas filled relays with hard contact materials "make
only" relays.
Another advantage of SF6 gas filled relays
is that they do not emit hazardous X-rays because the electrons
collide with the gas molecules and are unable to accumulate sufficient
energy to make significant radiation.
Recommendation - SF6 Gas filled
relays are recommended for many non-RF high voltage applications
For non-RF applications and for relays over 10kV, SF6 gas filled
relays are the most forgiving of all the high voltage relays. Because
they have SF6 gas inside rather than vacuum, the leakage current
is generally lower and more repeatable over long periods of non-operation.
And because of the gas, they are the most forgiving should the
contacts have to make an abnormal load in case of equipment failure.
So ...
if your load is not RF, we recommend you first take a look at the
relays rated for "make
only". The
exception is our reed relays and G81 rated about 10 kV that are the best
relays for these voltages where space and cost are important.
High Voltage Relay* Performance Comparison
with
different dielectric and contact materials
| Application |
SF6 Gas |
SF6 Gas |
Vacuum |
Vacuum |
| |
Tungsten/Moly(2) |
Copper
(Special Applications) |
Tungsten/Moly(2) |
Copper |
Carry Only
(DC) |
GOOD
But the gas increases the contact resistance resulting
is less current being carried than in vacuum
|
BETTER
than hard contacts but the gas increases the contact resistance resulting is less current being carried than in vacuum |
GOOD
But not as much current as copper contacts |
BEST |
Carry Only
(RF) |
N0
The gas will interfere with the RF carry capabilities |
N0
The gas will interfere with the RF carry capabilities |
GOOD
But not as much current as copper contacts |
BEST |
Make & Break |
GOOD
for make
but only low currents on break |
GOOD
for make
but only low currents on break |
BEST |
FAIR
Extremely low currents only |
Make
Only |
BEST |
BETTER
But not as good as hard contacts |
GOOD
But not as much current as copper contacts |
FAIR
Extremely low currents only |
Long Periods of Non-Use
Or where
Low and Stable Leakage Current
Is Needed |
BEST
Only relays listed
"Make only"
|
BETTER
than hard contacts but the gas increases the contact resistance
resulting is less current being carried than in vacuum |
GOOD
Generally will "burp" when HV is applied |
GOOD
Generally will "burp" when HV is applied |
Does not apply to GIGAVAC reed relays
 Contact GIGAVAC for specific make and break relay ratings in your application
04/02/08 |